The Z5IIC is indeed pretty much a Z5II, but without the viewfinder up top. In the hand it feels like, operates like, and performs like a Z5II, which is to say: quite good.
While there are a few simplifications—no second card slot, no extra battery grip capability, lower resolution on the Rear LCD—those really don’t come into play in use.
Many might think the resolution difference on the Rear LCD might make a difference, but in practice, it doesn’t. You’re still looking at something akin to a QuadVGA monitor, and typically at arm’s length. It’s brightness that is a key factor in the usability of an arms-length display in sunlight that would be the true limiting factor, and what Nikon has given us here works quite well in daylight conditions, though you may end up wanting to crank up the Monitor brightness setting some (+1 or +2 is all I needed).
As a carry-everywhere camera, the Z5IIC works as a jacket-pocket camera with the right lens. Basically you want a small lens that doesn’t stick out past the front of the hand grip, which rules out the 24-50mm kit lens. The 26mm f/2.8 is my current preferred lens for the Z5IIC if its going to be in and out of jacket pockets a lot.
I can’t over emphasize the fact that Nikon did not weaken the image performance or control customization in making this Z5II variant. The Z5IIC is the most versatile, performant, and easily controlled “compact” currently on the market.
Nikon targeted casual use for this camera, but it goes way deeper than that, considering that it has advanced features such as Pixel shift shooting. As a first dedicated camera for a social media or influencer creator, the Z5IIC has a broad and deep feature set and capability that can be grown into (same as with the Z5II itself).
So here’s the thing I’m still trying to figure out in my own practice: if all need is a Z5-level camera with me, is it going to be the Z5IIC or the Z5II? Again, in practice they’re near identical except for the added viewfinder on the Z5II. This boils down to something simple right now: is the camera going to be carried and in and out of my jacket pocket (suggests Z5IIC), or am I going to trying to follow action in bright light with a long telephoto lens (suggests Z5II).
From the initial reaction on introduction, it appears that a lot of Nikon users were critical of Nikon putting effort into making a Z5IIC, but so far, I’m all for it. It’s a tool that fits comfortably into my gear closet so far, and has ended up replacing my Fujifilm X100VI for carry everywhere.